Not Belonging to a Club That'd Have Me as a Member

Sometimes what makes a guy interesting is his interest in me.

Now, that sounds really arrogant and that's not how I mean it.

It's more like "Hmm, he's interested in/likes me? That's interesting. I wonder what makes him tick? I wonder what makes him the type of person that'd be interested in me?"

Sometimes a guy I might not have originally considered becomes a consideration when his buddy or my buddy mentions the fact that he wants to get to know me. That makes me take notice.

Am I making any sense?

No? Didn't think so.